Steps to Take if Your Appraisal Comes in Low
April 15, 2025
Is this a deal-breaker? Believe it or not, it isn't the end of the road. A low appraisal can sometimes be just a bump in the road. In other cases, you may wish to walk away from the deal. Here's your game plan to navigate this situation:
Step 1: Understand Why
Do you know why the FHA requires an appraisal in the first place? They're backing your loan, often because you have a smaller down payment or less-than-perfect credit. The appraisal ensures the property is worth the loan amount and has a remaining economic life for the duration of the mortgage.
Step 2: Details, Details
Ask your lender for a copy of the appraisal report. Understand the appraiser's reasoning and the comparable sales they used. This info is key for your next steps.
Step 3: Talk to the Seller
This is often your best first move. Show the seller the appraisal report and explain that the FHA loan will only cover the appraised value. Ask them to lower the price.
Any other VA or FHA buyer will likely face the same issue. They might agree to keep the deal alive, especially if they need to move. Be open to meeting in the middle, but know your limit.
Step 4: Consider Paying the Difference
Do you love the house? Can you afford to pay the difference in cash? But think this through. Can you afford it without hurting your finances? Is the home worth more than the appraised value in the local market?
Step 5: Challenge the First Appraisal
Work with your agent to find recent sales of similar homes that sold for more than the appraised value. Give this data to your lender. They might ask the original appraiser to reconsider. Appraisals are typically done a second time only due to deficiencies in the original. You can't contest an appraisal just because you don't like the dollar amount.
Step 6: Know When to Walk Away
If the seller won't budge, you can't pay the extra, and the appraisal challenges don't work, it might be time to walk. FHA loans allow this without penalty.
Step 8: Other Options?
Chat with your lender about other loan types. Maybe there's something with different appraisal rules. But if the house is truly overpriced for the local market, this might not solve the core issue.
Your Bottom Line:
A low FHA appraisal isn't the end of the world. Stay calm, get informed, and work with your agent and lender. Your best bet is usually to try and negotiate with the seller. Know your finances and your contract, and don't be afraid to walk away if it's not the right deal for you in the local market.
FHA Loan Articles
April 30, 2025 In a previous post, we discussed why FHA borrowers should carefully consider whether paying for discount points truly serves their best interests, focusing on factors like short-term homeownership, opportunity cost, FHA mortgage insurance, and the prevailing interest rate environment. Discount points are an option for borrowers willing to pay a fee to lower the interest rate by a set amount. This is not right for all borrowers, and you don't want to pay for points you won't benefit from during the loan term.
April 29, 2025Are you considering buying a home with an FHA loan? You'll likely talk to your participating lender about FHA loan "discount points" – fees you pay upfront for a lower interest rate on your mortgage. The idea behind discount points is a straightforward exchange: you spend money today to reduce your interest rate. Typically, one point equals one percent of your total FHA loan. In return, your interest rate might decrease by an amount you and the lender agree upon.
April 28, 2025Home loans have various expenses that aren't apparent to a new borrower until much later in the process. What do you need to consider when making your home loan budget? It might not be complete without addressing some of the issues we cover here.
April 23, 2025 While the prospect of lower interest rates or more favorable loan terms can be enticing, there are situations where waiting is the better option. Refinancing without carefully considering your current financial circumstances is never a good idea, but careful planning in the current financial environment is even more important.
April 22, 2025First-time home buyers worry about loan approval, but there are important steps to take to increase the likelihood that the lender will approve their application for the loan or pre-approval. What do you need to know before you choose a lender?
